Skip to Main Content

Self Paced Lesson - Tertiary and Secondary Legal Materials - Subject Guide: 5: Tertiary Materials

 

NOTICE: This guide is currently under review, with a new guide to be launched before Semester 1, 2025. In the meantime, please direct any queries or feedback about this guide to the Library's Digital Experience via our Enquiry and Feedback form.

Researchers should not assume that the plain meaning of a word or phrase is necessarily the same when it is defined in an Act of Parliament or in a court case.

There are two types of legal definitions:

Definitions in Cases: A judge clarifies the meaning of a word or phrase in their judgment, this is referred to as "words and phrases judicially defined".

Definitions in Acts: Words and phrases are defined by parliament in legislative instruments such as Acts and Regulations.
You need to make sure that the Act you are looking at is relevant to the jurisdiction in which you are working.
Also be aware of the limitation of the definition with an Act.
If a definition is not given in an Act, you should look at the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) and the Interpretation Act 1984 (WA) to see if they provide a standard definition which applies to all acts unless otherwise stated.

There are many legal dictionaries both in print and online, but they do not all hold the same value and importance in Australia as they do in the country of publication.
Meanings can vary from one jurisdiction to another. For example, do not assume that a definition that you find in a U.S. online dictionary is valid in Australia.
Similarly, do not assume that a word defined in a Victorian court has exactly the same meaning in WA.
However, when you can't find a useful definition in Australia you should consult whatever sources you can find, but you must use them with caution.

Other than the dictionaries recommended for purchase by your lecturers, the main reference dictionaries you should consult are:

  • Encyclopaedic Australian Legal Dictionary (Lexis Advance): one of several online legal dictionaries, and one of the few online Australian dictionaries.  
  • Words and phrases judicially defined in CaseBase on Lexis Advance and on Westlaw Australia.
  • Australian Law Dictionary on Oxford Reference.
  • United Kingdom

Official AGLC Dictionary

Rule 1.9.1

Spelling should comply with the latest edition of the Macquarie Dictionary.

Where alternative spellings are given, the first-listed should be used.

Where a word is not included in the Macquarie Dictionary, the Oxford English Dictionary should be used.

Sourcing Legal Definitions on Lexis Advance

Searching Lexis Advance Dictionaries

Words and phrases judicially considered
on Lexis Advance

Lexis Advance has two dictionaries:

As well as legal dictionary definitions, words and phrases can be defined in court cases.

Most cases on Lexis Advance have a CaseBase entry, which gives an overview, as well as the full text of the judgment.

Judgments are useful, as they

  • set out all interpretive rules used
  • contain facts and analogous cases to illustrate legal concepts
  • show the judge’s thought process

Use Library Search to access these dictionaries by typing in the title
Example: "Australian Legal Words and Phrases"

 

Complete tutorials: 

(open these links in an Internet browser OTHER THAN Chrome)

Legal Definitions in Westlaw Australia

Westlaw Australia does not include a legal dictionary.

However, legal terms can be found within The Laws of Australia or in case law.

 

The Laws of Australia

Case Law

Step 1: 

Select Content Type -  The Laws of Australia

Step 1: 

Select Content Type -  Cases

Step 2: 

Select Advanced Search

Step 2: 

Select Advanced Search

Step 3: 

Navigate down the screen to the Words & Phrases search box 
Enter the search terms in the Words & Phrases search box
For this example, enter "vicarious liability".
Select  Search.

Step 3: 

Navigate down the screen to the Words & Phrases search box 
Enter the search terms in the Words & Phrases search box
For this example, enter "vicarious liability".
Select  Search.

Step 4: 

Open the result

[33.6.590] Vicarious liability is an example of strict liability1 imposed for policy reasons.

Step 4: 

Open the result

New South Wales v DC [2017] HCA 22

Note the pop up:

Step 5: 

Note the document path and currency of the article:

The encyclopaedia article includes relevant legislation and cases that discuss or define the search terms.
Links are in the footnotes.

Step 5: 

Return to Results list

Open the result

Ingram-Nader v Brinks Australia Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 624

 

 

Step 6: 

The Digest summarises the aspect of vicarious liability considered in this case.
In this instance, it is concerned with human rights, and the vicarious liability of employer.

Scroll down to the Words and Phrases Judicially Considered section.
A term included in this section indicates that it has been discussed at length in the judgment.

Use Ctrl+F to search on the page for vicarious.
Navigate to the section Vicarious Liability.
Here you can see how the judgment refers to legislation and case law.

 

Stroud's Judicial Dictionary of Words and Phrases

Stroud's Judicial Dictionary of Words and Phrases, from the United Kingdom, is one of the most respected sources of definitions in the common law world.
It is an important tool for lawyers and law students to use, less important for business and legal studies students.
It is a multi-volume work which is available in print in the Law Library's Reference Collection at R 340.03 STR.
TIP: if you cannot find the word, check if there is a supplement

Stroud's is a wonderful dictionary that will help you legally define "lard", "lawyers" and "life prisoner".
Stroud's defines "at once", "at or near", "at the time", "at work" and "asylum".
It informs us that in the UK the case between Robinson v Everett [1988] Crim LR 699 confirms that a "stuffed and mounted golden eagle" falls within the definition of a "Dead Wild Bird" for the purposes of The Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (UK) s 1(2)(a).

According to the first edition of Stroud's in 1890:

"Its chief aim is that it may be a practical companion to the English-speaking lawyer, not only in the Mother Country,
but also in the Colonies and Dependencies of the Queen.
The hope is also indulged that it may be not without utility to the man of business, nor without interest to the student of word-lore" (vii).

Tip:

Google Books provides a Preview of print books

e.g. The Judicial Dictionary of Words and Phrases Judicially Interpreted by F. Stroud

The Internet Archive also has reproduced copies:

 e.g. The Judicial Dictionary of Words and Phrases Judicially Interpreted

Australian Law Dictionary on Oxford Reference

  • Access the Australian Law Dictionary 
  • You can
    • browse entries alphabetically
    • search within work using the search box to the left of screen
  • Included in the definition are key cases and related terms
  • If you cannot find a term in the Australian Law Dictionary, you can search all of Oxford Reference by adding your search term to the Search box at the top right of screen
    • ​results will be sourced from a significant array of general English language dictionaries as well as specialist dictionaries

Task:

Search for the definition of vicarious liability

Step 1:

Access Library Search
Search for the title "Australian Law Dictionary" 


Select the link eBook Full Text Online from the relevant result

 

Step 2:

Search for the term "vicarious liability"

 

Step 3:

Note the case law referred to in the definition:

Encyclopaedias and dictionaries are also known as Tertiary Materials, as they compile, list or digest information from other sources

Tertiary materials provide an overview and background on a topic, but are not considered acceptable material upon which to base academic legal research.

It is important for you to become familiar with one of the main starting points for legal research: encyclopaedias.
Encyclopaedias contain broad overviews of a subject area, and give some structure to further research and study.
They are an excellent source of finding relevant primary legal sources such as cases and legislation.

As a law student you should take time to look at the contents pages of a chapter or section.
Consider a table of contents as a conceptual map or framework of the key elements of a subject - it can point out the components of a particular area of law.

When should you use an encyclopaedia?

Legal encyclopaedias can be useful tools for legal research, particularly in the beginning stages of research, but should not be your only research resource.

Legal encyclopaedias provide:
    topic overviews
    main concepts
    historical turning points
    references to key authorities - cases and legislation

In this topic your task is to use the two Australian legal encyclopaedias and consider them as potential starting points for your research.
The two encyclopaedias are:
    Halsbury's Laws of Australia (available via the database Lexis Advance)
    Laws of Australia (available via the database Westlaw Australia).

Read the information in the following tabs, then work through the Self Test Questions to become familiar with access and navigation..

Halsbury's Laws of Australia on Lexis Advance

Research topic: Source information about whether marriages made under duress are valid.

Accessing Halsbury's Laws of Australia

Method 1

Step 1: Search for "Halsbury's Laws of Australia" using Library Search

Step 2:  Select the link to Lexis Advance in the Access online section of the catalogue entry

Step 3: Enter your MAIS login and password if prompted

 

Method 2

Access Halsbury's Laws of Australia from the Lexis Advance homepage:

Step 1: 

From the Publications list on the right-hand side of the screen, locate Halsbury's Laws of Australia

Step 2: 

Select the drop-down arrow beside Halsbury’s Laws of Australia

You can choose to:
- search Halsbury's Laws of Australia  by selecting Go to Advanced Search
- browse Halsbury's Laws of Australia by selecting View Table of Contents

Step 3:

Select Go to Advanced Search from the dropdown menu


Task: Source information about whether marriages made under duress are valid Task: Source key cases on a topic when given one case:
In the Marriage of Teves III and Campomayor (1994) 122 FLR 172

Step 1:

Search for this information by entering search terms into the Terms search box.
Enter:      marriage AND (duress /25 (valid! OR void OR vitiate))

Note the use of Boolean Operators:

  • the truncation/stemming symbol ! in valid! will search for:
    • valid
    • validity
    • validate
    • validation
  • the proximity limiter /25 will search for words within 25 words (about the length of a sentence) of each other (any order)

 

Step 1:

Search for this information by entering search terms into the References to Cases search box.

Enter "122 FLR 172"

Step 2:

The results screen will show you a wide variety of information including:

  • The Narrow by filter options (you can see the filter for Halsbury's is already listed)
  • The number of documents found.

Results can be narrowed by Content Type or Legal Topics.

Research can also be searched for additional search terms.

Narrow the results by Legal Topic Family Law

Step 2:

Select the relevant chapter from the Results list

Tip:  To be taken to the place in the chapter where the search term appears, click on the link to View this passage in full document

 

Step 3:

Navigate through the results list and locate the relevant chapter
(A) Marriages Recognised as Valid

To access the text of the chapter, click on the chapter title.

Step 3:

Navigate through the Notes to identify cases related to the relevant point of law

Tip:  Scroll up to the in-text reference to clarify the context of where the case is referenced.

Once you have accessed the chapter make a note of a few features:

  1. The Document Path is given, which provides a conceptual map of where you are within the encyclopaedia.
  2. The currency of the paragraph is given under Last updated:.
  3. You will also see the content of the paragraph and the related footnotes.
  4. In paragraph [85-550], the footnotes are longer than the paragraph!
    Note the details of the primary sources of law are relevant to this paragraph.

 

Navigate through the chapter and paragraphs by search terms

Option 1: Search terms by frequency
Select the drop-down arrow next to All terms in the toolbar
Select duress from the list of search terms
Select the down arrow next to the Terms box to navigate to the word duress

Option 2: Search terms by location on navigation bar
Select the drop-down arrow next to All terms in the toolbar
Note the colour for the search term valid
Slide the blue focus square to the purple line to locate the term in the text

 

Halsbury's Laws of Australia on Lexis Advance Interactive Tutorial

Research topic: Are marriages made under duress valid?

Complete:

The Laws of Australia on Westlaw Australia 

Research topic: Find information about the duty of care for solicitors in relation to wills.

 

Search The Laws of Australia

Browse The Laws of Australia

Step 1: 

Select Content Type The Laws of Australia

Step 1: 

Select Content Type The Laws of Australia

Step 2: 

Select Advanced Search

Step 2: 

The chapters in The Laws of Australia are arranged alphabetically.

Navigate down the list to 

Step 3: 

Complete search fields:

All of these terms field:            wills AND "duty of care"

Legislation Cited (Title) field:   "Wills Act 1970"

Step 3: 

Expand relevant Chapters by clicking on +

  

   

 

 

          

 

Step 4: 

Click on the magnifying glass icon to Search

This is a more serendipitous way to arrive at a relevant paragraph.

However, if you are unsure of your search words, expanding chapters can prompt you in the right direction.

Step 5: 

The results screen will show you a wide variety of information including:

  • The Search Summary;
  • The number of documents found.

At the time of writing, this search returned only 1 result.
The law is constantly changing and in turn, so too will the amount of commentary.

Navigate down the Results list and locate the paragraph with the number 36.3.1040.

Click on the paragraph title:

[36.3.1040] Executors, in their capacity as executors, owe a general duty of care to beneficiaries of the estate.

Step 6: 

The top of the paragraph shows you the 'breadcrumb' or path within the Laws of Australia.

This is valuable to you as it provides you with a conceptual map of where you are within the encyclopaedia.

Selecting the paragraph title will also change the left side of the screen, opening up the hierarchical table of contents for the encyclopaedia.
Browse within this hierarchy by selecting the View Full TOC button to access related parts of The Laws of Australia.

 

Once you have accessed the paragraph [36.3.1040] make a note of a few features:

  1. Details of the paragraph number will be reiterated under Citation.  
  2. The currency of the paragraph is given under Current as at.
  3. The Document Path is given, which provides a conceptual map of where you are within the encyclopaedia.
  4. You will also see the content of the paragraph and the related footnotes.
    The footnotes provide details of the primary sources of law which are relevant to this paragraph.

 

You should never quote from a legal encyclopaedia.
Instead, you should quote directly from the primary sources of law given in the footnotes.

Activity indicator1.    Halsbury's Laws of Australia

Task: Use Halsbury's Laws of Australia to research the topic: Are marriages made under duress valid? 

Which of the following paragraph numbers discusses this topic?

a. 85-525
b. 85-550
c. 85-555

Response:

Activity indicator2.    Currency

What is the currency date for the paragraph you selected above?

a.    07 March 2019
b.    17 December 2017
c.    11 January 2016

Response:

Activity indicator3.    Supporting primary materials

Which one of the following cases is cited to support this sentence: "A mistaken belief that the ceremony performed abroad is not a valid marriage under Australian law does not affect the validity of the consent"?

a. Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Edwards (1997) 21 Fam LR 829
b. In the Marriage of Teves III and Campomayor (1994) 122 FLR 172
c. Re B (1983) 9 Fam LR 40
d. Marriage of Barriga (No 2) (1981) 7 Fam LR 909

Response:

Activity indicator4.    Context

In which Halsbury's title does this discussion take place?

a.  Marriage and Divorce
b.  Conflict of Laws
c.  Registration of Births, Deaths and Marriages
d.  Family Law

Response:

Activity indicator5.    Citing 

Read the rules given in AGLC for citing encyclopaedias. 6.3; but please remember that you should find and cite more in depth analysis than you can find in an encyclopaedia.
Which of the following is the correct citation for paragraph [85-550] in Halsbury's Laws of Australia whe
n accessed via Lexis Advance?

a. LexisNexis, Halsbury's Laws of Australia (at 11 January 2016) 85 Conflict of Laws, 'II Choice of Law' [85-550].
b. LexisNexis, Halsbury's Laws of Australia (at 17 December 2017) 85 Conflict of Laws, '(A1) Family Law' [85-550].
c. LexisNexis, Halsbury's Laws of Australia (as at 07 March 2019) 85 Conflict of Laws, 'Exceptions to recognition' [85-550].

Response: